Travis Scott and Don Toliver Sued by Producer Early Yellow, Who Claims He’s Owed Royalties on the JACKBOYS Hit ‘What To Do?’
Travis Scott and Don Toliver are being sued by a producer who says his work helped build one of the biggest records off the JACKBOYS project — and that he never got the recording money he says comes with it. The lawsuit, filed Tuesday (Nov. 17), comes from Israeli producer Niv Kalisky, who works under the name Early Yellow. Keep this part straight from the jump: everything in the filing is his allegation. No court has ruled on any of it, and the other side has not answered yet.
THE CLAIM
Kalisky says he provided a beat that was sampled in “What To Do?,” the Travis Scott and Don Toliver record from the 2019 JACKBOYS compilation. Here’s the twist that makes this case different from the usual sample fight: his name is already on the song. The official credits list Niv Kalisky as one of the songwriters, and the album’s liner notes credit “Earlyyellow00” with additional production and a publishing share. Kalisky says he has been paid publishing income as a writer — and that is not what he’s suing over.
What he claims he’s owed is a cut of the master — the money the actual recording earns from album sales, streaming and sync licensing. According to the complaint, he and his team sent multiple written requests for payment to Cactus Jack Records and Sony’s Epic Records, and the suit alleges those requests went unresolved, met with promises that never turned into payment. His team also filed takedown requests with Spotify and Apple Music, and the complaint says Sony answered with counter-notices to keep the record up.
His own portfolio backs up how he sees his role: Kalisky’s site lists “What To Do?” among his projects and describes his work on it as co-composer, co-producer and co-lyricist. The same portfolio lists production and composition work for Hoodrich Pablo Juan and Omy De Oro.
THE FILING
Billboard, which obtained the complaint, reports the case was filed November 17 and brings copyright infringement claims — his lawyers describe it as a suit over the “unauthorized use” of his work. The defendants named go well beyond the two headliners: Travis Scott, Don Toliver and Sheck Wes — who has additional vocals on the song — plus Cactus Jack, Sony and Epic Records, and other producers involved with the track.
What he’s seeking, per the complaint, is a portion of the revenue the recording has generated — from sales, streams and licensing. No specific dollar figure has been reported. His attorneys, Justin M. Jacobson and Daniel Cruz Hernandez, put the filing in plain terms in an exclusive statement to AllHipHop: “Today we filed suit on behalf of our client, producer Early Yellow, against Travis Scott, Don Toliver, Sheck Wes, and Sony/Epic, among others, for the unauthorized use of Early Yellow’s work on the platinum hit ‘What To Do’ as part of the ‘Jackboys’ project. Producers are becoming more aware of their rights and the need to properly protect themselves. As a result, today our client chose to stand up for what he deserves and believes in and we are here to support him in this endeavor.”
THE SONG
“What To Do?” is track six on JACKBOYS, the seven-track Cactus Jack compilation released December 27, 2019 on Epic and Cactus Jack. The song is billed to JackBoys and Travis Scott featuring Don Toliver, with additional vocals from Sheck Wes. The production is credited to Mike Dean, London Cyr and Jenius, with additional production from Earlyyellow and Sarah Schachner — the same credit Kalisky says never came with master money. The writers on the record are Jacques Webster, Caleb Toliver, Khadimou Fall, Mike Dean, James Cyr, Julius-Alexander Brown, Niv Kalisky and Sarah Schachner.
The project was no small release: JACKBOYS debuted at No. 1 with 154,000 equivalent album units and 97.1 million on-demand audio streams in its first week, and Kalisky’s lawyers describe “What To Do?” itself as a platinum hit. That is exactly why the distinction at the center of this case matters — a songwriting credit pays on the composition, but the master is a separate pot of money owned separately, and Kalisky claims his contribution earned him a seat at both tables.
THE OTHER SIDE
So far, there is no public answer. Representatives for the defendants did not immediately respond to Billboard’s requests for comment, and neither Scott’s camp, Toliver’s camp, Cactus Jack nor Sony/Epic has put out a statement on the filing. Until they respond in public or in court, the only version of events on the record is Kalisky’s — and it is important to treat it that way.
WHAT’S NEXT
The defendants will have to answer the complaint, and cases like this usually turn on paperwork: whatever agreement, if any, governed Kalisky’s contribution back in 2019, and what the labels can show was actually paid. If the two sides can’t settle it, a judge will decide whether a credited writer with an additional-production credit is also entitled to a share of the recording revenue. Either way, it’s a reminder of how many hands touch a hit record — and how long the money arguments can outlive the music.
Source: AllHipHop’s exclusive reporting, including the statement from Early Yellow’s attorneys (Nov. 17, 2026); complaint details as obtained and reported by Billboard (Nov. 17, 2026). Song and album credits from the JACKBOYS album liner notes and official listings.